Monday, October 26, 2009

Monad Cont.

I posted a comment on McCall's original monad post. However, this goes in a bit of a different, perhaps mildly less relevant, direction.

Over break I was camping, and sitting around the fire one night found myself in a very strange game involving word association and spelling. Don’t ask. Anyhow, to get to my point, I decided to try to stump everyone by using the word monad. This resulted in a rather intense debate over the meaning of the word, which somehow led to a discussion of scientology.

Though most of us there were less than well educated on the subject, a few among us (including myself) had known someone that had been involved with that “religion.” The important aspects can be summarized as follows: scientology works by establishing places or times in your life when you have hit a road block – perhaps when you were four and bullied, or forty and fired. What the religion can do about this is to “clear” you, and allow you to move on and succeed at whatever you are doing. Furthermore, it performs this action for only a few thousand dollars a session.

I think that this would epitomize what Horkeimer and Adorno feel like the effect of the culture industry has been on religion. Would you agree? It seems that scientology has bent the purpose of religion from guiding people to live their life in accordance with an afterlife or moral god, to a purpose of economic success. A stranger thought, perhaps they would say that this is the religion not for the laymen or factory workers, but for the bourgeois in the modern period. Look at the primary advocates (i.e. Tom Cruise). Does this mean that even the people in charge have become merely subjects to the culture industry? Simply to the machine of industry itself?

It’s taking over the world…

2 comments:

  1. Wow,
    Not to bash you Scientologists out there, but this religion (if you want to call it that) that believes in evil alien spirits possessing human beings to account for all the evil in the world, and having to rate individuals on a meter of thetan levels rated by an electropsychometer meter scale to detect changes in a persons mind, is just absurd, not to mention an auditing fee and membership fee to become a scientologist. Just wow. This is obviously a prime example of the culture industry having its impact on the culture of religion. It is clear exploitation, and the fact that people really buy into this stuff just blows my mind. And as Mike mentioned, the notion of the bourgeoisie representation through popular celebrities such as Tom Cruise justifies that the industry of capitalism and economics has infiltrated the area of religion. In no way would Horkheimer or Adorno ever consider Scientology a form of religion, just as a means of exploiting the ignorance of the American people by establish fallacy and fiction into their lives to receive profit.

    Wow.

    ReplyDelete
  2. By the way, I found this information off the Scientology website:
    http://www.scientology.org/#/videos/

    ReplyDelete